The Foreplay has an insane amount of gain compared to most line preamps (unpadded, it will be around 25dB).
Which Foreplay do you have? The original Foreplay premaps are on 6"x10" chassis plates, and the Foreplay III is on an 8"x10" plate.
The Foreplay III has padding resistors on each set of inputs to deal with the excess gain in the preamplifier, and these can be changed out to alter the gain. Based on your assertion that there isn't enough gain, this is most likely the case. If you have the manual, it gives some values for pads on the inputs and describes their installation. You would need to measure what you have now to know what alternate values you might want.
-PB