Hello Fishfood,
Welcome to the forum!
If you plug in 1/4" headphones into the jack, then pull them out slightly, you can bridge the left and right channels with the headphone plug itself, which may appear to be a problem, but is not.
If, on the other hand, you are yanking out one RCA plug and finding that you have sound on both channels, that's an unfortunate issue that needs your attention.
Is there any way you can post a picture of the top and the bottom of this amplifier for us? This will help us identify the amp for you, and perhaps we can e-mail you a manual so you can begin troubleshooting.
If I had to guess, I would suspect a possible error in wiring from the output transformer, but it'd be best to know that everything else is hitting the marks first.
-PB