The Craftsman specifications are up to 10 digits error on the AC scales, which means +/-1.0 volts on the 200v scale. So your meter does not have the ability to accurately measure 2.5vAC. If the tubes glow and it sounds good, don't worry.
What is happening is that there is a rectifier in the meter, which causes a small error, perhaps around 1 volt. It will always read low on small voltages. At 200 volts, a 1-v error is very small, but at 2 volts it is not small at all! It is significantly more complicated to make a meter that will read low AC voltages accurately.