Just a bit of an update. Since this was my only phon preamp, I invested in a cheap phone preamp that handles both MC and MM. The only cartridge I currently have is a Hana SL. When I connected it to my turntable and then to the Beepre via MM, I got the exact same response and I did on the Eros. Nothing... Keep in mind I have that connected to a external SUT. Once I pulled the SUT out of the line, the MC portion of the cheap preamp worked and I had how shall I say descent sound but no where near what the Eros could produce. Me Soundsmith cartridge is currently in for rebuild and is still weeks off, so I purchased a inexpensive MM to use as a spare. That should arrive in a few days, and I will check that on the MM part of the preamp. I think there is a chance that the problem my lie in the SUT, but it seems strange to me that both sides would go out within minutes of each other.
Just a note: I checked every single resister on both sides and they have all of the same voltage within a 10th of a volt.
With this info, any further ideas?