I may have a rather embarrassing admittance to a mod I made a couple years. If you remember, I added a balance potentiometer to my BH Crack.
Well, upon investigating my circuit tonight, it appears I severed the ground connection that links the 9-pin socket to terminal 3. If you look at my PEC pot photos, you'll notice that I no longer have a connection between the upper and lower lugs closest to the 9-pin socket. I DID have this connection in the past. If this is the case, it is 100% my fault, and this would explain the voltages being seriously off.
Photos are of my PEC pot.