Thanks Grainger for your input,but I understand fully what paul is saying and in theory I completely agree with him. But when I checked this am the filiment voltage was up to 5.7 volt,the regulator obviously can not decide on a filiment voltage, I am not worried about stripping or damage to any tube.Paul is with the paul Joppa, the final word in experience and total understanding of just about anything thats in this forum,they are giants. I am learning but Paul is light years ahead any of my thinking. I am saying only that the tube is BAD. And on that one thing,Paul is wrong. Thanks Paul and Grainger. PS if I am wrong I will accept it,but until that time I would not bet on it