A harsh thumping sound is likely a cold solder joint that's moving around a little bit from the vibration of the adjacent keyboard.
Actually, it was the bigger 6080 tube! I tried the original RCA that it came with, some Sylvania tube, and some GE tube. The GE tube gave decent results. I kept looking to see if I had another tube and I found some philips ECG tube, and now it's dead silent no matter what. My left ear is relieved now.
The reason I thought it might be the tube is that even though tapping the amp anywhere with a pencil eraser caused the microphonic effect, tapping it at the tube caused it to be ever so slightly louder.
Or maybe it was a bad solder joint and swapping the tubes made the joint be better connected and thus be working again, idk.
thanks though!
Now time to get a better pot lol
Edit: Plugging back the tube brought the issue back. huh