How close are you to 5V at terminal 16? Does this voltage follow one of the 300Bs?
If the voltage follows a tube, you just have a ridiculously strong 300B, but the EH300B tends to be exceptionally consistent. If the voltage doesn't follow a tube, then I would be suspicious that the volume pot/balance control are not properly grounded on that side of the amp which is throwing off the biasing a bit.
-PB