Hey Greg (bro) I can dig where your coming from, but I think there is (are) reasons for why we think (feel) that we like sound 'A' over sound 'B'. I do believe they can be isolated and bottled. Nobody likes pain when they listen (harshness, hard dynamics), and nobody likes mud (distortion, jitter, blurring of notes, etc.). Digital has much of the above if not done right. Analog tends to not have as much of those unless the amplification path is not right. Both conditions are common in audio playback. I believe that good sound to Joe Blow is good sound to Joe Goldenear. The big question is: how to get it, and how much does it cost.
With the huge generalities aside, there are a huge number of variables in the path from 'A' to 'B'. Ok so where am I going with this...Oh, ok, so we have the audiophile axiom 'everything makes a difference'. I didnt coin that phrase. I do believe it though. Now for example, if barbed wire sounds 'good' then it sounds good. I'm not sure it does. I dont know if anyone has ever listened to it. It seems that it would not sound good, but you dont know. Until someone tries it.
Thats were crazy people (like you and I - lets be honest), come in. Look I'm from upstate NY. Right there I have the credentials for being an audio 'eccentric'. Thats the kind of person(s) that wonder what CAN be. Anyway, let know what you know about the barbed wire thing...
Yours - Eric
Eric
Emotiva XPA-2, Magnepan MMG (mod), Quickie (mod), JRiver, Wyrd4sound uLink, Schiit Gungnir, JPS Digital power cord, MIT power cord, JPS Labs ultraconductor wire throughout, HSU sub. powered by Crown.