Is $25 a good price for a new record?
In 1970, give or take a couple of years, the list price of an LP was $12.99. Granted, one rarely paid that amount and you could get factory cutouts for $2.99-$4.99. But, today that $12.99 price tag would be listed at about $80.00. So in relative terms, I would say "hell yes, $25 is a good price for a new record." Besides, most of the new LPs come in at 180 grams or more. I still have some 1970 LPs that must weigh 90 grams and move in the wind like a piece of paper. The few new LPs that I have purchased in the last few years, I have found to be superior in quality to the ones we purchased in the 60's and 70's..though there is the rare exception on both sides. Also, LPs manufactured during the 70s energy crisis are of inferior quality, since a lot of the vinyl was of inferior quality and often made from recycled material due to the "oil crisis." I actually purchased about six copies of the "Sunfighter" LP, because it would start hissing after about 24 plays. Consequently, when buying used vinyl I avoid these years.
I do agree with trying to buy at Goodwill, ARC, etc. Though as mentioned, they have gone up considerably in price in the last two years. In fact, I can get quality used vinyl at a used record store for a cheaper or slightly higher price than Goodwill and the rest. I know the used record shop only sells vinyl of VG or better quality, and so that is where I target most of my purchases now days. If one is diligent, then it is possible to "stumble" into a great deal at Goodwill. My wife went in right after they had priced a persons record collection. All of the LPs had protective covers, were labeled for his library, and in like new condition. Given that is was "discount" day, she ended up buying about 50 like new LPs for $100...Elton John, Cat Stevens, Steely Dan, etc.