Its a Christmas miracle.
I removed the MJE and stuck it back on and resoldered all other pieces, and the hiss is gone, the LEDs on the 9 socket are on, and we're golden. When doing this work, I didn't secure the small boards down to the standoffs, and when I thumped the problem board with my finger, you could hear it in the headphones, while the other board was silent when I thumped it. SO its still not perfect.