The Aleph J has almost 20dB of gain and your speakers don't need more than about 2W or so to play exceptionally loud. 2W into 8 ohms is 4V, and your amp will make 4V with only about 400mV of input signal. The weakest sources I have ever found put out 300mV of output, so most are going to be close to doing the job without any preamp gain.
Having said all this, -12dB is probably not enough, but definitely a good place to start and then you could scale your potentiometer resistors accordingly based on what you learn.