So yes it was definitely a tube issue. I got a replacement tube, put it in and there was a firework show inside the replacement when I switched the amp on. My guess is that tube was bad as well. Luckily, I ordered a couple more replacements off eBay. I removed the C4S board and replaced the 150k resistors. Previously, one of the LEDs went out so I wanted to just kind of start fresh and deal with the C4S after I get the amp working properly. So now, 2 new tubes in there. Voltages have improved. Voltages that are off:
A1-36
9- rapidly fluctuates bet 45-52
B1-18
19-rapidly fluctuates bet 18-21
No sound from right channel. If I turn the gain all the way to the max, sound then kicks in at right channel